If you are craving a warm, melty sandwich toasted to perfection, look no further than Potbelly Sandwich Shop. Known for its vibrant neighborhood vibe, antique decor, and signature warm bread, Potbelly has grown into a go-to destination for lunch and dinner nationwide. Beyond their legendary sandwiches, the menu features a rich lineup of freshly tossed salads, comforting soups, hearty mac and cheese, crisp chips, hand-dipped milkshakes, and fresh-baked cookies.
The Potbelly Experience: What Makes It Special?
Potbelly started as a small antique shop in Chicago back in 1977. To draw in visitors, the original owners began selling toasted warm sandwiches to antique shoppers. The warm, hearty food quickly stole the show, transforming a boutique shop into an iconic fast-casual sandwich brand.
What sets Potbelly apart from other sandwich chains?
-
Toasted Perfection: Every sandwich goes through a conveyor oven, melting the cheeses and lightly crisping the bread.
-
Signature Hot Peppers: Potbelly’s secret weapon is its blend of giardiniera hot peppers, which adds a crave-worthy kick to any meal.
-
Versatile Sizes: Sandwiches come in standard sizes (Original), lighter options (Skinny), or massive portions (Big/FLAT), allowing you to tailor your meal to your exact hunger levels.
-
Hand-Dipped Shakes: Made with real ice cream and topped with an iconic mini butter cookie on the straw.
Potbelly Menu Items and Prices
Note: Prices may vary slightly depending on your specific location, local taxes, or whether you order in-store versus via third-party delivery apps. Prices listed below reflect standard in-store averages.
1. Toasted Sandwiches
The centerpiece of Potbelly’s menu is its selection of hot, custom-built toasted sandwiches. You can choose your bread (Warm White or Multigrain) and customize toppings like lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard, oil, vinegar, and hot peppers.
| Sandwich Name | Key Ingredients | Standard Price (Original) |
| A Wreck® | Turkey breast, hickory-smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, and Swiss cheese | $9.59 |
| Italian | Capicola, mortadella, pepperoni, salami, and provolone cheese | $9.59 |
| Avo Turkey | Hand-sliced turkey breast, Swiss cheese, avocado, and cucumber | $10.09 |
| Chicken Club | All-natural grilled chicken, Applewood smoked bacon, and cheddar | $10.09 |
| Fiery Island Chicken | Grilled chicken, provolone, jerk sauce, and fresh avocado | $9.69 |
| Prime Rib Steak | Tender prime rib, Swiss, caramelized onions, and garlic aioli | $11.39 |
| Mama’s Meatball | Beef and pork meatballs in marinara sauce with melted provolone | $9.59 |
| Cubano | Slow-cooked pulled pork, smoked ham, Swiss, pickles, and deli mustard | $9.59 |
| Pizza Melt | Pepperoni, capicola, meatballs, marinara sauce, and provolone | $9.59 |
| Veggie Melt | Fresh avocado, mushrooms, Swiss, cheddar, and provolone | $8.89 |
| Turkey Breast | Hand-sliced turkey breast and Swiss cheese | $8.89 |
| Smoked Ham | Hickory-smoked ham and melted Swiss cheese | $8.89 |
| Tuna Salad | 100% Albacore tuna salad and Swiss cheese | $8.89 |
| Grilled Cheese | Simple and delicious melted cheddar cheese | $8.09 |
2. Soups, Chili & Mac
Whether eaten as a main dish or paired with a sandwich, Potbelly’s hot soups and comforting mac and cheese are customer favorites.
| Menu Item | Description | Average Price |
| Mac & Cheese | Creamy three-cheese macaroni cooked to rich perfection | $6.59 |
| Chili Mac | Hearty beef chili blended directly with three-cheese mac | $6.59 |
| Chicken Pot Pie Soup | Tender chicken breast, veggies, and a flaky pastry crust topping | $6.59 |
| Loaded Baked Potato Soup | Creamy potato soup with bacon, cheddar, and green onions | $6.59 |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup | Creamy cheese soup packed with tender broccoli florets | $6.59 |
| Hearty Beef Chili | Classic beef chili with kidney beans, peppers, and onions | $6.59 |
3. Fresh Salads & Wraps
If you are looking for lighter options, Potbelly serves big, crisp salads loaded with premium proteins and house-made dressings, as well as hearty wraps.
| Item Name | Ingredients Highlights | Average Price |
| Powerhouse Salad | Grilled chicken, avocado, hard-boiled egg, cucumber, and hummus over greens | $9.49 |
| Apple Walnut Salad | Grilled chicken, blue cheese, apples, dried cranberries, and candied walnuts | $9.49 |
| Chicken Salad Salad | Chicken salad, provolone, cranberries, cucumbers, and tomatoes over greens | $8.88 |
| Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap | Grilled chicken, avocado, tortilla crisps, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle lime | $9.99 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap | Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and buttermilk ranch | $9.99 |
4. Shakes, Desserts & Sides
No visit to Potbelly is complete without treating yourself to a fresh-baked cookie or a thick, hand-dipped milkshake.
| Item Name | Details | Price |
| Hand-Dipped Shake (Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry) | Made with real ice cream and topped with a mini cookie | $6.79 |
| OREO® Cookie Shake | Real ice cream blended with crushed OREO cookies | $7.19 |
| Cold Brew Shake | Cold-brewed Arabica coffee blended with vanilla ice cream | $7.19 |
| Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie | Baked fresh daily in-shop | $3.19 |
| Sugar / Brownie Cookie | Soft, chewy, fresh-baked desserts | $3.19 |
| Dream Bar | Rich chocolate and oatmeal bar layered with caramel | $3.59 |
| Zapp’s Potato Chips | Voodoo, Jalapeño, Salt & Vinegar, or BBQ flavors | $2.79 – $3.09 |
| Potbelly Dill Pickle | Whole crisp dill pickle | $1.69 |
Combo Options: Getting the Best Value
If you want to try multiple items without overspending, Potbelly offers smart meal pairings:
-
Pick Your Pair ($14.29 – $16.29): Combine a Skinny Sandwich, a half-size salad, or a cup of soup/mac & cheese to customize your ultimate lunch combo.
-
Make it a Meal Deal ($5.29 – $8.58): Add a bag of chips with a drink or upgrade your beverage to a hand-dipped milkshake for an additional fee.
Tips for Ordering at Potbelly
To get the most out of your meal, keep these local ordering tips in mind:
-
Don’t Forget the Hot Peppers: If you enjoy spice, ask for their famous hot pepper mix added to your sandwich or grab a jar to take home.
-
Order via Potbelly Perks: Joining the loyalty program earns you free food, birthday rewards, and exclusive promotions.
-
Customize Your Bread: You can choose between Warm White, Multigrain, or ask for your sandwich served flat or in a wrap if you prefer less bread ratio.
Final Thoughts
The Potbelly menu offers much more than toasted sandwiches. From popular choices such as A Wreck, Italian, Turkey Breast, and Chicken Club to salads, soups, chili, sides, shakes, smoothies, and desserts, there are plenty of options for different tastes and appetites. Potbelly also emphasizes made-to-order food and customization, allowing customers to adjust many meals to their preferences.